How to Sell Consulting Without Feeling Salesy

I've told a LOT of people not to hire me.

And some of those people have come back and hired me later. Others have sent me referrals because they remembered that I was the person who DIDN'T try to sell them something they weren't ready for.

Here's why.

When I'm talking to a potential client, my goal isn't to convince them to hire me. It's to figure out whether I can actually help them, whether they're ready for that help, and whether what I offer makes sense for their situation.

Sometimes the answer is no!

I've talked to people who were so early in their businesses that investing in my program simply didn't make sense yet. They needed more experience, more clients, or more time figuring out what kind of business they wanted to build before they were ready to get the full value out of what I teach.

And I tell them that.

Because the last thing I want is someone spending a significant amount of money with me when I don't think they're in a position to get a great return on that investment.

That's the biggest shift I want you to make if selling your consulting services feels uncomfortable: stop going into conversations trying to GET the sale, and start trying to figure out whether you SHOULD make the sale.

It changes everything.

Why selling feels so slimy in the first place

I once asked a room full of business owners how they felt about selling.

The answers were things like gross, pushy, slimy. You can practically picture the sweaty guy in the cheap blazer trying to convince you to buy something you don't want. 😂

And I get it! We've ALL been on the receiving end of those conversations.

Someone is pitching us something, we're not sure we want or need it, and instead of helping us figure that out, they keep trying to convince us.

It's uncomfortable.

And because we don't want to make other people feel that way, we start dreading our own sales conversations.

But I think a big part of the problem is that we're approaching sales with the wrong goal.

If you get on a call thinking, "I really need this person to hire me," you're already putting yourself in a difficult position.

Now you're listening for opportunities to pitch. You're trying to say the right thing. You're worrying about objections. You're thinking about how much you need the money.

And whether you realize it or not, the prospect can often FEEL that.

Because at that moment, making the sale has become more important to you than figuring out what's actually best for them.

No wonder it feels gross!

Now imagine approaching that same conversation from a completely different place.

You're genuinely curious about the person, what they're trying to accomplish, what's getting in their way, and whether you're the right expert to help.

And you're perfectly willing to tell them if you're not.

That's a VERY different experience for both of you.

Stop assuming the client knows what they need

Let's say someone contacts you and says, "I need a new five-page website. Can you give me a quote?"

Most service providers will immediately start asking about the pages, features, timeline, and budget so they can put together a proposal.

But what if you said:

"Hold on a second. Tell me a little more about what you're trying to accomplish. Why do you think you need a new website?"

Maybe they want more leads.

Maybe their current website isn't converting.

Maybe they've changed their offer and their messaging no longer reflects what they do.

Or maybe their website is perfectly fine and the actual problem is that nobody is visiting it!

If you immediately quote the website, you might be selling them something that won't even solve their problem.

But when you stop and ask questions, something interesting happens.

The prospect starts to see that you're not just another service provider eager to take their money.

You're an expert who's actually looking out for them.

And that makes you stand out IMMEDIATELY.

Because most people are so busy trying to prove they can do the work that they forget to question whether the work is even what the client needs.

Your job isn't to sell the client what they ask for. It's to help them figure out what will actually get them the result they want.

And sometimes that means telling them they don't need what you sell.

Why I stopped giving away my best thinking in free proposals

There's another problem with the traditional way consultants sell their services.

We give away an enormous amount of our expertise for FREE.

Think about what happens when someone asks you for a proposal.

You have a conversation, ask questions, try to understand their situation, think through what they need, and then put together your recommendations.

Sometimes you even start giving them strategic advice right there on the call because you want them to see how smart you are and how much value you could bring.

And then you send them a proposal and hope they say yes.

Sound familiar?

The problem is that you're often doing some of the most valuable work you do BEFORE anyone has agreed to pay you.

And you're doing it with limited information, because you haven't had the opportunity to really dig into the client's business.

Which means you might be proposing the wrong solution entirely.

Let me give you an example.

Two interior designers. Which one would you hire?

Imagine you're looking for someone to redesign your home.

You speak to two interior designers.

The first asks you to send over some photos, tell her about your style, and share a few examples of rooms you like. She puts together a Pinterest moodboard, gives you a general idea of what she'd recommend, and sends you a proposal.

Pretty standard, right?

The second designer tells you she'd love to help, but before she can recommend anything, she needs to understand how you actually LIVE in your home.

So she offers you a paid first engagement.

You spend a couple of hours walking through your house together. She asks about each room, what you love and hate, how your family uses the space, what frustrates you about the current setup, and what you'd love your home to feel like.

Then she creates a detailed plan explaining what she'd change, why she'd change it, and how those changes would make your home more beautiful, functional, and enjoyable to live in.

And here's the best part: the plan is yours.

You could hire her to implement it, hire someone else, or even do some of it yourself.

You've paid for something valuable, whether or not you ever hire her again.

Now, which designer would you feel more confident hiring for the bigger project?

I'm guessing the second one!

Because you've already experienced what it's like to work with her. She's demonstrated that she understands your needs, has a thoughtful process, and knows how to get you the result you want.

She didn't have to convince you with a fancy proposal.

The experience of working with her did the selling.

That's the idea behind what I call the Lead Product Method.

Instead of giving away your most valuable thinking in free consultations and proposals, you turn that thinking into a small, paid first engagement that delivers a complete, valuable result.

And the people who buy it are much more likely to want to continue working with you because they've already experienced the value of your expertise.

Why "I'd definitely buy that!" means absolutely nothing

There's another reason I love getting people to take a small paid first step.

Because people saying they're interested and people actually PAYING for something are two VERY different things.

I learned this at a workshop I attended on how to create paid workshops. (Very meta, I know. 😂)

There were about 50 of us in the room, and we were all working on our workshop titles.

A few people shared their ideas, and the instructor asked the rest of us to raise our hands if we'd attend based on the title alone.

Hands shot up everywhere!

Everyone's ideas sounded amazing. People were enthusiastic. It looked like there was demand for practically every workshop being proposed.

Then the following week, one of the participants who had gotten rave reviews from the room actually launched her workshop.

She shared the ticket link with the same people who had enthusiastically raised their hands.

Guess how many bought a ticket?

ZERO.

Not one person!

And I don't think anyone was being dishonest when they raised their hands.

It's just that imagining buying something and actually taking out your credit card are completely different experiences.

In theory, all kinds of things sound great.

But when someone actually has to spend money, they're evaluating the decision differently.

That's why I don't put much stock in people saying, "Oh, I'd definitely pay for that!"

Show me the person who ACTUALLY pays for it.

When someone pays you for a Lead Product, even if it's a relatively small investment compared with your main service, they're demonstrating a real commitment to solving their problem.

And that changes how they show up.

They're more invested in the process, more likely to do the work, and more serious about the outcome.

Which makes the entire relationship better.

My process for selling consulting services without feeling pushy

So how do you put all of this into practice?

In my No BS Business Model, which I teach in my book Scale Solo, the sales process starts with two simple steps: a Fit Call and a Lead Product.

The Fit Call is a short conversation to figure out whether there's a potential fit.

That's it.

You're not trying to diagnose the entire problem, give away an hour of free consulting, or convince someone to buy your big engagement.

You're trying to understand enough about their situation to determine whether you can help and whether they're a good candidate for your process.

If they're not a fit, tell them!

Maybe you can refer them to someone else. Maybe they're not ready yet. Maybe what they need simply isn't what you do.

And if they ARE a fit, you explain your process and invite them to take the first paid step.

That's the Lead Product.

During that engagement, you dig into their situation, diagnose the real problem, and create a strategic plan for how to get them the result they want.

They walk away with something valuable, whether or not they continue working with you.

And if the next logical step is your larger consulting engagement, you can recommend it with confidence because you've actually done the work to understand what they need.

You're no longer guessing at the scope or trying to convince someone that your services are worth the price.

You've demonstrated your expertise, built trust, and established a clear path forward.

And the client gets to decide whether they want to continue.

You can learn more about the full process in my Lead Product Method.

The best sales process doesn't feel like selling

I think this is one of the biggest misconceptions about selling premium consulting services.

People assume they need to become better at persuading, handling objections, or convincing prospects that they're worth their prices.

And sure, being able to communicate the value of your work matters.

But I've found that the most effective way to sell isn't to become more convincing.

It's to become more confident in your process and more committed to helping people make the RIGHT decision.

Sometimes that decision is to hire you.

Sometimes it's not.

And when you're genuinely okay with either outcome, the entire conversation changes.

You stop feeling like you're chasing people.

Prospects stop feeling like they're being sold to.

And instead, you're two people trying to figure out whether working together makes sense.

That's how you sell consulting without feeling salesy.

Not by avoiding sales conversations, but by making them about helping people instead of convincing them.

Want to learn the whole model?

Get instant access to the free masterclass that breaks down the whole model so you can do it too.

FREE MASTERCLASS

Next
Next

How to Manage Client Expectations Without Letting Clients Run Your Life